FREEBIE: electric teal nail polish, free in In Style magazine! _MakeuPanda

I got this polish free with In Style magazine, we needed it, since they are normally £11, it seemed a crime not to!
I already have one similar to the nude-y one, but am still wanting the orange one!!
So this teal colour is called electric teal and is by Nails Inc.

And with a base coat, and two coats (I think, it may have been one) it looks like this:

Yes, yes, I do need to learn how to paint nails properly...

Next I decided to add on my new elf matte-ifying polish,

So it looked like this.

With or without the matte finisher?
I like it shiny best, I think, but the matte finish is a nice change and it's more "fashionable", I suppose.
Which do you prefer?
xxx